DANNEMORA
FEDERAL CREDIT UNION

A digital marketing case study.

Dannemora Federal Credit Union (DFCU) is a community-focused credit union that provides personalized financial services to individuals and businesses in Northern New York. Known for its member-first approach, DFCU offers a range of products including checking and savings accounts, loans, and digital banking tools. They emphasize both accessibility and financial education, with resources tailored to support members in achieving financial well-being. Their slogan, “Small enough to know you, large enough to serve you,” reflects their dedication to combining local service with comprehensive banking options.

3,298,394

Impressions

$2,407,799

Total Deposited

16.94%

CTR, exceeding 5.7% industry benchmark

596

Total Bank Account Opened

USSA24 Finalist Badge3 1

the problem to solve

Smaller credit unions like DFCU face competition from larger, well-known financial institutions. With the population of DFCU’s field of membership being limited to anyone who lives, works, attends school, or worships in Clinton, Essex, Franklin, or St. Lawrence Counties in New York, we had to think outside the box to attract as many brand-new members as possible with three clear goals in mind:

  1. Increase new account holders & deposits by 20% in one year for their Kasasa Cash Back® checking account, aiming to open 193 new accounts.
  2. Boost brand awareness within their field of membership.
  3. Meet or exceed the industry benchmark of 5.7% for search click-through rates (CTR) in the Finance & Insurance sector.

the strategy

Phase 1

Awareness & engagement

To position Dannemora Federal Credit Union (DFCU) as a trusted financial partner, we designed a multi-channel strategy that went beyond typical financial marketing. We crafted visually engaging and informative ads showcasing the unique benefits of Kasasa Cash Back® checking accounts, carefully balancing aesthetics and data-driven messaging. These ads were launched across Facebook, Instagram, and the Google Display Network, tailored to DFCU’s ideal audience.

What made our approach distinct was the precision of our audience targeting. By leveraging advanced data segmentation, we pinpointed individuals not only by location and interests but also by their active intent—focusing on behaviors like researching checking and savings accounts, comparing financial institutions, and exploring personal banking solutions. This ensured that every impression worked toward driving both product and brand awareness with maximum efficiency.

Phase 2

Conversion & retention

Once we had established a strong foundation of awareness, we focused on driving measurable results. Our Google Search campaign was built to capture high-intent traffic by targeting keywords directly aligned with account openings. To stand out in a competitive landscape, we employed dynamic and persuasive call-to-action messaging, guiding users through a seamless process to open accounts online in minutes.

To ensure we left no opportunity on the table, we implemented a robust retargeting strategy. By re-engaging users who had previously visited the website but had not yet converted, we created multiple touchpoints, delivering personalized follow-ups that reignited interest and guided users toward completing their journey with DFCU.

THE RESULTS

how did the campaign perform? we’re glad you asked.

dannemora ads collage

campaign overview

start date

JUNE 2023

end date

MAY 2024

digital performance metrics

total impressions

3,298,394

total clicks

14,793

account growth targets

projected lift

20%

actual lift

34%

deposit growth targets

projected lift

20%

actual lift

23.5%

channel-specific results:

google search

14,664

impressions

2,152

clicks (ctr: 14.68%)

facebook & instagram

2,399,494

impressions

11,066

clicks (ctr: 0.46%)

programmatic display

884,236

impressions

1,575

clicks (ctr: 0.18%)

account growth results:

Total Bank Accounts Opened

596 new accounts opened

from June 1, 2023 – May 31, 2024

Kasasa Cash Back® Checking Account:

272 accounts

achieving 140% of goal, exceeding the goal of 193 new accounts

Kasasa Cash® Checking Account:

118 accounts

achieving 231% of goal, exceeding the goal of 51 new accounts

Kasasa Saver® Savings Account:

206 accounts

achieving 194% of goal, exceeding the goal of 106 new accounts

deposit growth results:

Total Deposits

$2,407,799 deposited

June 1, 2023 – May 31, 2024 achieving a 23.5% increase in deposits received

Kasasa Cash Back® Checking Account:

$246,266

deposited achieving our deposit goal of $230,000

Kasasa Cash® Checking Account:

$1,179,532

deposited achieving 165% of goal, exceeding deposit goal of $715,00

Kasasa Saver® Savings Account:

$982,001

deposited falling slightly behind our target of achieving $100,000

But we didn’t just stop at account & deposit growth; we also knocked it out of the park with our marketing performance:

  • Kasasa Checking PPC Performance: Achieved a CTR of 16.94%, exceeding the 5.7% industry benchmark.
  • Brand Awareness PPC Performance: Reached a CTR of 13.66%, exceeding the 5.7% industry benchmark.

The campaign’s impressive engagement rates, particularly on paid search, indicate the effectiveness of the targeting and ad content. The high click-through rates on various platforms reflect successful outreach and engagement with potential members. DFCU not only met but exceeded its account growth targets, achieving 596 new accounts and $2,407,799 in total deposits by the end of May 2024. The actual account lift of 34% and deposit lift of 23.5% surpassed the projected 20%, underscoring the campaign’s success in driving customer acquisition.

{

“Working with Threshold has made a significant impact on our ability to grow new accounts for our Kasasa Checking products. They truly understood the unique needs of our community and crafted a PPC strategy that was both budget-friendly and targeted to the right members. We saw a remarkable 34% increase in Kasasa accounts!

The collaboration has been seamless, and we look forward to continuing our partnership to better serve our members and communities.”

{
- Brad Currie, Director of Digital Services & Innovation // - Anna Hewitt-Channel, Business Development & Marketing Manager

This campaign taught us that good things happen when you listen to your audience. By conducting thorough target audience analysis, we were able to target DFCU’s perfect customer based on interest, demographics, and buying behavior. Casting our net deeper, not necessarily wider, helped us attract qualified leads that converted.

Threshold’s digital marketing campaign for DFCU proved highly effective in promoting its Kasasa checking & savings account products and attracting new members. By leveraging the unique benefits of Kasasa Cash Back® combined with a strategic digital approach, the credit union achieved significant growth and surpassed its performance goals. This success positions DFCU as a powerhouse in a field steeped with competition.

CONTACT

Let’s get those creative juices flowing.

It’s not every day that you have the opportunity to make a lasting impression. But with Threshold, you do. Let’s get talking—it’s free!